5

I work at a large engineering and software company. There are several construction teams working inside our facility for some structural work.

I was speaking with one of the electrical workers in the hall and mentioned to him that we could hear his team working upstairs, cracking jokes, singing and having fun while working.

He had this shocked look on his face and said you heard all that!?

Then to scare him, I said I really like that song __ too!

He said I am so sorry, etc. etc....

I said no way, I really enjoy it, don't stop!

Then he told me that when his team first started working here they were "wondering who we are and where we came from" and "who are these people and do they ever smile?" becuase it sounded like a library in the office space.

OUCH!! (..sometimes we don't realize how different we look in other peoples eyes and yes it is me too.)

Now, in no way am I saying the office space should become a party atmosphere or the set of SNL. It should stay professional and productive but is this just the difference between blue and white collar at the work place?

In my experience anything other than serious and professional, you looses credibility - and fast.

(1) Are blue collar workers happier?

(2) Is it possible to get some of what they have in the white collar world or is this just wanting it all?

closed as primarily opinion-based by Jim G., jcmeloni, CincinnatiProgrammer, Adam V, IDrinkandIKnowThings Nov 22 '13 at 15:36

Many good questions generate some degree of opinion based on expert experience, but answers to this question will tend to be almost entirely based on opinions, rather than facts, references, or specific expertise. If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • 2
    Hey Greg, love the question! I think it could probably use a bit of focus with an edit since you have two separate questions: (1) why are blue collar workers happier? (2) how can I make a white collar office more relaxed? – jmac Nov 21 '13 at 23:56
  • 1
    Having worked in a company where the staff had "fun" while getting their work done, and one where they were very serious and "heads down, get on with it", I can state that from my experience both got similar amounts of work done, and the former were much, much happier. – Jon Story Dec 11 '14 at 10:14
12

Executive Summary

Having worked in manufacturing (business side) for the better part of a decade, I think the difference in attitude toward the working atmosphere is focused around three things:

  1. Hourly Pay
  2. Clear Goals
  3. Fewer Politics

Applying these to the white collar world works a bit differently, but is doable.

Clear Goals

Blue collar work is typically measurable. If I assemble widgets, then the widget factory knows the average widget-assembler will assemble X widgets per hour. My goal is to assemble at least X widgets per hour. If I achieve that goal, I am virtually guaranteed gainful employment so long as widgets need assembling.

The output of blue collar work is tangible. If we need 10,000 widgets, we know they will take 500 man-hours to assemble. Whether or not those widgets will be sold or not is something the widget-assembler can do absolutely nothing about, and so he doesn't have to worry about it. If he reaches his quota on time, the widget-assembler can go home happy.

White collar work is a lot fuzzier. While many businesses create KPIs, achieving a KPI target does not mean that your business will be successful -- your business is to make the company money, and no amount of waving your KPI history in front of management will help if you still use frames on your company website because there was no KPI to tell you to change it.

Hourly Pay

As a blue collar employee, because your work is so closely tied to the amount of time you work, your work is the hours you get paid for. There tends to be less unpaid overtime, or unrealistic expectations of output. When you are off the clock, you are off the clock, and don't have to worry about your progress meeting the next week with your department manager. Either you made your 20 widgets per hour or you didn't, and there isn't much sense of wasting time worrying about it.

White collar jobs are generally salaried, and no amount of waving a contract saying, "But my hours are 9-5!" will help if you end up missing a deadline and losing out on a significant contract for your company. Creative work does not scale directly with hours, and you could spend 18-hour days looking for a way to solve a business problem and never come across it, or you could take off from work early to pick up your kid and have it come to you while waiting in front of his school in a stroke of insight.

Because your brain is always on, white collar work has a higher potential to seep outside of work hours and make it more difficult to take your work in stride.

Note: this is not to say that blue collar workers don't think, and the best workers of all walks of life do think quite a bit, but thinking about a concrete goal vs. an abstract goal are two very different things

Fewer Politics

With clear goals, and output tied to time worked, there are a lot less politics in blue collar jobs. If something doesn't get done properly, since the goals are clear, and the amount of hours put in are clear, it is far easier to point a finger, and far harder to dodge blame.

White collar jobs are fuzzy, and aren't related to time work, so it is insanely easy to point fingers when something goes wrong. Even if everything is going right, there will be people who don't actually do any work, but coast along on the power of their personality, taking credit for other people's success, and/or turning a non-event in to a major victory because nobody really knows what contributes to business success anyway.

Putting it Together

If you're with a group of people who know the goals, know how long they will be there, and know they will be held responsible if they don't get the job done, you want to make it as easy for everyone else to get their job done as possible. Ever done something tedious like stuffing envelopes, or painting a house? So much of it is mindless muscle memory that you end up joking around with the people around you to make the task more enjoyable.

For white collar offices, I have found success with the following:

  1. Make sure people know what their job is
  2. Make sure people have some slack in their schedules
  3. Be friendly

The offices I have been happiest in are the ones where I am in front of customers. When you are directly reminded of what you are working for, it is much easier to focus on a tangible goal (giving them value). I have generally found that the more a white collar person is around customers, the more relaxed they end up being because they are confident in what they need to do to achieve the company's goals.

Constantly being busy is a bad thing. If people are overworked, minor irritations cause people to overreact, pleasantries become a luxury that can't be afforded, and someone making a small mistake that impacts your work becomes a Serious Problem™ that can cause ripples of discontent through the office. Making sure there are enough people to do the job, and that people have some free time to let them breathe goes a long way to making people more pleasant.

But the number one thing that makes a workplace more jovial is being friendly yourself. My last job was in a Very Serious Company™ that tended to discourage smiling, laughter, or fun in the office (save it for after hours, folks). I'm a generally fun person (I'd like to think) but I'd found myself taking on the dour personality I had been acclimated to. When I switched jobs I told myself I would make an effort to be the fun guy to prevent the office from being the same sort of dour.

After joining my current team, conversation increased many-fold, people joked around, had friendly competitions, and people actually voluntarily associated in their free time. Coworkers got to know each other's families, and when we came across something that would have made us irritated at work, we'd show it to our teammates and laugh at the ridiculousness of the situation rather than getting upset.

Offices are living breathing entities, but we can affect them. So long as people know what they need to do, have time to do it, and are surrounded by people they like, you can make it a more pleasant place to be.

  • 1
    IME the politics are just different in blue collar, and there's usually a more obvious minimum standard of sociability. People still crash through that, but IMO it's there. Possibly it's also at a lower level - no-one demands erudite conversation from every blue collar worker. But at the extreme, blue collar workers are more likely to have disabling or fatal "accidents" if they're widely disliked. Aside from that, good summary. – Móż Nov 22 '13 at 1:20

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.