How to know if I deserved to be promoted? I am in a mental mess thinking that maybe they promoted me to team lead because my manager didn't have another option and couldn't wait for one? I know I have it in me. But who doesn't? I constantly think others are of the opinion that I was promoted because 1) Either I threatened to leave OR 2) Because they didn't have any one else interested in the job

This is because people ask me questions like 1) What did you actually bring to the table OR 2) Did you threaten them with another job offer and they promoted you?

It is very disheartening when I hear such questions. Please advise.

Note: I had earlier thought that my team was going to downsize and thus let go off me. When I shared this with my boss, she said everything was OK. And 5 months down the line I got promoted.

Also, before I shared my concern with my boss, she had persistently asked me about my opinion to change to a lead role. So at least in her eyes, I deserved it.

But what about the others who think I wasn't deserving of the promotion? How do I deal with their comments and questions?

closed as off-topic by gnat, Chris E, Xavier J, The Wandering Dev Manager, mcknz Nov 30 '16 at 18:30

This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:

If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • So you said you were gonna leave and then they promoted you? What's the problem? Are you unhappy there? Why does it matter if you deserved it or not? Your employer just wants you to do a good job at it. – Nelson Nov 30 '16 at 6:19
  • @Nelson - in fact, I thought they would sack me! When I discussed this with my boss, 4 months down the line, the promotion happens. Not that she did not ask me before this conversation about what I thought of the role. Meaning she probably thought of promoting me even before i had the above discussion with her. – Helen Nazareth Nov 30 '16 at 6:23
  • 3
    Hmm, you thought you were gonna get fired, but you got promoted instead. Probably just need to stress out less and just not worry about it. You're obviously doing something right to get a promotion. – Nelson Nov 30 '16 at 6:24
  • I dont understand if they promote you it mean they think you deserve it, if later you do badly then it is their problem not yours, you just need to do your best with your new role. Also who ask you that question looks really rude. – kirie Nov 30 '16 at 10:21
  • I think you have the impostor syndrome. You will need a couple of victory under your belt to go from thinking you have it in you to know you haveit in you. Buckel up and give your best! – François Gautier Nov 30 '16 at 14:17

How to know if I deserved to be promoted?

I suggest that this question may not be the right question to be asking. What one "deserves" depends on the point of view: your manager's, your peers', yours, etc. (For instance, my mom has always thought I deserve to be President...so what? Maybe I should have sold more real estate...but I digress). What really matters is not what you deserve but what you actually end up getting. We can all probably think of managers who in our eyes definitely did not deserve to have any authority over other human beings. But someone else thought differently, and here they are. Bottom line: if you are promoted, that means you 'deserved' it in some shape or form, from the perspective of those in authority to promote you. That's really all that matters and there is no point mulling this over. You are now a lead. Great. It happened. Now just do your best being one, and don't lose sleep over whether you deserved it in the first place.

maybe they promoted me to team lead because my manager didn't have another option and couldn't wait for one?

Maybe. Or maybe not. Or maybe both. Or neither. Again, thinking about this won't help you, your peers, or your manager. This is a classic type of issue that is really, really worth doing your best to just let go trying to rationalize, and instead to focus on doing the work, each day at a time. If it helps, keep in mind that change always ignites speculation, initially. But just when you think it all through and feel like you got everything organized in your head, you discover that the world has moved on and that other people have other problems to occupy themselves with, and it's water under the bridge. Was it worth all the agonizing? In hindsight, probably not.

I know I have it in me. But who doesn't?

I can easily think of some people who don't, and you probably can, too. I am sensing deeper issues of self-esteem, and need for approval and validation, which may be driving the constant tendency to compare oneself with others. Listen, there is always going to be someone who deserves to be in your shoes more than you (or so you, or they, or their mothers, think). But guess what, the same is the case about them. It works both ways. So, it really doesn't matter. I would recommend to work on your self-appraisal and to try to move away from constant comparison, and toward finding that inner 'center' which allows you to find happiness and joy in each day regardless of what others think (or may think!) of you.

Did you threaten them with another job offer and they promoted you?

People are people, they say odd stuff all the time. In this case the obvious implication is, "did you only get promoted because you threatened with leaving, rather than business need, your supervisory ability, or manager's good judgment?" Such thoughts cross just about everyone's mind. But some people do a much better job keeping such stuff inside, and quietly resolve these inner doubts. Others let it all out, and leave you to deal with their projected insecurities. The point is, their insecurity should not become your problem. Work on building up your internal psychological walls to prevent their issues from spilling over and consuming your mental and emotional energy. Learn to distance yourself from such questions and thoughts. Humor is a great tool for this. So is calling them on it: "Yeah, you know, I fugured the ONLY way I would ever get promoted is to threaten them, rather than try to earn it. Obviously that worked! You should try it."

But what about the others who think I wasn't deserving of the promotion? How do I deal with their comments and questions?

See above. Hopefully some of these ideas and strategies will help you deal with these questions and comments. Good luck!

  • Thanks @Aymor! This gives me a lot to think about, and act upon. Certainly need to build those emotional walls a little more higher. – Helen Nazareth Nov 30 '16 at 17:35
  • @HelenNazareth, Great, thank you for your feedback. If you think the answer was helpful, please feel free to upvote and/or mark as accepted anwer ;) – A.S Nov 30 '16 at 18:13

In many organisations, if you are a senior developer looking to make the jump to lead, it's often the case that you will be working the role already before you get promoted.

So, even though you thought you were "just" a senior developer did you:

  • Mentor junior members?
  • Have senior members of the team asking for direction in terms of code/problems/architecture?
  • Get brought in to a project purely to solve a difficult specific issue?
  • Manage a team's work load for a deliverable?
  • Manage stakeholder relationships?
  • Are you an expert in translating your particular businesses requirements into technical specifications?
  • Are you seen within the team as taking a leading, controlling role whenever something needs to be done?

If you answered yes to a number of those, you probably are already doing the team lead role and didn't know it, in which case, congratulations on receiving recognition of your actual role.

  • I was doing a few of them, yes. The others I couldn't since back then I didnt have the authority. But I am doing them now. – Helen Nazareth Nov 30 '16 at 17:34

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.