13

A close friend of mine whom I have known through graduate school is asking me to recommend her for a position for which I feel she is ill-suited for. One of the requirements of the position is strong communication and customer service ability. Through my work with her in school on projects, I feel she does not qualify. Clear communication of ideas is not her strongest suit.

I do not want to sour the relationship nor for my friend to think that I am personally against her as a person. How should I let her know that I do not feel comfortable recommending her?

Thanks and I appreciate it!

11

I usually just say "sorry, I'm really bad at writing recommendations, so I don't think you want me to do one for you." Most folks won't push past that.

If she insists, then you may need to tell her "OK, I'm willing to write a recommendation, but I don't think you want me writing one for this position. I just don't think this job's a great fit for your strengths as I see them, and that would be reflected in the recommendation. I like you, I think you've got a lot to offer a company, but this wouldn't be the position I'd hire you for."

2

You have a few options and I'd say something like the following:

I'm sorry but I don't feel comfortable recommending you because... [pick one of:]

  • we never worked closely together in workplace setting so I can't credibly vouch for your work
  • I've only been with my current employer for X months
  • I don't know enough about the position/team you're applying for
  • I feel uncomfortable injecting myself into the hiring process as I don't want personal bias to affect the selection process

but I wish you all the best in your search.

If the nature of your relationship allows it, you would be doing your friend a real kindness if you were honest with her though. Some people go years without the kind of feedback they'd need to establish a professional attitude and workplace ethic. Some people can't be helped but many that were poor students or unreliable team players in college become great employees with a bit of guidance.

Some of these were adapted from this article by Alison Green which I highly recommend reading. You should also keep her advice here in mind:

First, be sure that you really think she wouldn’t be good at the job — and that it’s not just that you don’t want to work with her. Because if it’s the latter, I can’t condone standing in the way of someone finding employment based just on a personal dislike.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.